Defamation

Defamation on Facebook and its legal consequences

While Facebook connects friends, there are also instances of insulting and defamatory statements being made public. It can be particularly disheartening if users activate the Facebook’s ‘like’ button in relation to such content. But what are the legal consequences of defamation of Facebook?

The consequences of defamation on Facebook ©-ferkelraggae-Fotolia-Fotolia_31081868_XS

The consequences of defamation on Facebook ©-ferkelraggae-Fotolia-Fotolia_31081868_XS

Defamation on Facebook

The number of cases which illustrate how Facebook can be used to disseminate defamatory material are growing. Stern TV recently highlighted a particularly tragic case.

A father took the life of his two children and then committed suicide. The distraught mother later discovered that a group on Facebook began to accuse her of murder. In reaction, the mother pressed charges for defamation.

False accusations of crime

The legal position here is clear. Before you accuse someone on Facebook of committing a crime, you should be sure of the facts.

The fundamental principle under German criminal law is ‘in dubio pro rea’ or in other words the presumption of innocence. This means that a person is considered to be innocent of a crime until they are proven guilty.

As a result of this principle, strict rules apply to the press when reporting on crimes and any possible suspects.

But the public too are not at liberty to freely publish information concerning suspects during a criminal investigation. After all, posts on Facebook are not private messages, but are public and can be quickly disseminated with widespread consequences. For this reason, publishing a suspect’s personal details, such as name, address and even a photo is prohibited. This protects the suspect’s personality rights.

On a civil law level, the person concerned can apply for an injunction and could claim compensation.

But publishing such information and assertions on Facebook also gives rise to criminal liability. Depending on their content, the statements could amount to insulting behaviour or even fulfil the elements for defamation.

Calls to lynch

Another particularly stark case of defamation on Facebook is that of a 17-year-old boy from Emden who was accused on Facebook of having murdered an 11 year old. Some of the Facebook commentators called for the boy to be lynched. They got off lightly and received only youth detention. In most cases, however, calling for the murder of a suspect can be severely punished.

Under § 111(1) German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB) a person who publicly incites crime is treated under German criminal law as if they had aided and abetted the commission of the crime. In turn, a person who aids and abets the commission of a crime is liable in the same way as a perpetrator.

This means that had the alleged murderer of the 11 year-old-girl in fact been lynched to death as a result of such statements, the authors of the statements would have been liable for incitement to murder. Luckily, such events did not transpire.

Nevertheless, by inciting a crime, the authors of the statements could have been sentenced to up to 5 years in prison (§ 111(2) StGB).

Private criminal investigations

Linked to this topic is the question of conducting private criminal investigations on Facebook.

The use of Facebook to privately search for suspects of a crime is not permitted. This principle was reaffirmed after the owner of a Cologne kiosk posted a CCTV video of the kiosk being robbed by two masked men.

In accordance with § 131a and 131b of the German Criminal Procedure Rules, only the authorities may conduct criminal investigations and search for suspects.

This ensures that the personality rights of the alleged suspect are properly protected and reduces the risk, as in the Emden case, of innocent people being publicly defamed. Such CCTV videos and other potential evidence should always be handed to the police.

Liking defamatory statements

It is currently disputed in the courts whether “liking” a post of Facebook can be considered a defamatory statement.

An employment tribunal in Dessau supports this position. The judges ruled that by liking a defamatory Facebook post, the person who activates the like button adopts the content as if it were their own and is therefore legally liable as if they had posted the statement themselves. However, when calculating the level of compensation, consideration is given as to who published the statement in the first place.

There is however developing legal opinion that a person who likes a defamatory statement on Facebook should not be treated as if they published the statement. This position argues that liking statements is too spontaneous and lacking in thoughtful consideration.

Given the number of Facebook likes that are activated every day, this argument may well have some substance.

How to protect yourself against defamation on Facebook

There are now various effective ways of reacting to insulting or defamatory postings on Facebook.

The quickest way is to complain to Facebook. Once the company acquires knowledge of illegal content, it is obliged to remove it. Facebook now usually reacts within 24 hours to requests from lawyers to remove content.

Often, it is important to victims of defamatory statements to find the author of the statements. To achieve this, there is a possibility to press charges against an “unknown” person. The prosecution service is then entitled to retrieve from Facebook, the IP address of the author and possibly related content. It is relatively easy for prosecuting authorities to find authors of defamatory statements on Facebook as most people are registered with the social network under their real names.

If minors or youths are the authors of the defamatory statements, they could be punished with juvenile detention and could face compensation claims. Depending on how severe the psychological stress caused is, the compensation claims can amount to several thousands of euros plus the reimbursement of relevant medical care costs.

Conclusion

Posting defamatory statements on Facebook can give rise to both civil and criminal liability, especially if they falsely accuse a person of having committed a crime. Particularly severe criminal consequences are also attached to calls for vigilante justice.

The legal position on ‘liking’ defamatory content on Facebook is less clear. While this is the case, Facebook users should give careful consideration to which published content they ‘like’.

Related articles:

Christian Solmecke is a partner at the law firm WILDE BEUGER SOLMECKE. He is the author of numerous legal publications in the area of internet and IT law. He is also an associate lecturer for social media law at the Cologne University of Applied Sciences.

Do you like this article? Feel free to rate it now:

1 Stern2 Sterne3 Sterne4 Sterne5 Sterne (6 Ratings, Average: 4.83 of 5)

RSSComments (11)

Leave a comment

  1. Anonymous says:

    I need some advice regarding this matter.

  2. cbd schweiz says:

    Is this the international law?

  3. Amelida Sophia says:

    I am very happy today to share this amazing testimony on how Dr. idahosa the herbal doctor was able to cure me from my HIV Virus with his herbal medicine. I have been a HIV patient for almost 8 months now and have tried different methods of treatment to ensure that I am cured of this terrible disease, but none worked for me, so I had to leave everything to God to handle as I was a Christian who had faith that one day God would intervene in my life, yet I felt so sad and desperate as I was losing almost everything due to my illness, A few months ago while I was surfing the internet I saw different recommendation about Dr idahosa on how he have been using his herbal Medicine to treat and cure people, these people advice we contact Dr. idahosa for any problem that would help immediately, I contacted Dr idahosa and I told him how I got his contact and also about my disease, after some time Dr. idahosa told me to have faith that he would prepare for me a medication of herbal herbs, he told me I would take this medicine for a few weeks and also asked my home for home address so as possible for him to submit the drug for me, so my good friends after all the process and everything Dr idahosa actually sent me the medicine, I took it as I was directed by Dr. idahosa, after a few weeks passed, while on Dr.idahosa medication I began to experience changes in my body, I had to call my doctor at the hospital for some blood test after test my hospital doctor told me that I was no longer with the Hiv virus and my blood is pretty good, I can not even believe this, Friends well today i am Hiv Free and i want everyone to know that there is a cure for Hiv for those who will contact Dr idahosa after reading my testimony, you can kindly contact Dr. idahosa in (dridahosasolutioncenter@gmail.com) or call him +2348134261542, God bless you all …

  4. rose terry says:

    I have heard of him before, but after watching his documentary “healing spell” I was turned on to the full story

    about Dr jaj. He is a man who has the Cure for AIDS/HIV and every kind of

    illness, through a whole foods vegetarian diet and natural herbs, what he calls Electric Foods. He went to herbal school college,

    and has thousands of testimonials of healing people with Herpes, HIV AIDS, and HPV several other

    illnesses. Lisa “Left Eye” Lopes of TLC was cured of Herpes by him and she was so moved by his knowledge that she went on

    to spread the word about him in every way she could. She also opened a Cultural/Healing Center for Children in USA

    before she passed away tragically. This all inspired me that i had to contact Dr jaj, because i was having AIDS

    which could not be cure but was only managed, when i contacted Dr. jaj, he sent me some herbs which i took, and now i can tell you, i

    have been totally cured of AIDS, My Name is ROSE, I am from the South Carolina, Please if you have any form

    of illness especially STD,Infertility,HIV etc. you can contact him immediately through his Email Address drjajspellhome@gmail.com or you can also call/whatsaap him on his number

  5. rose terry says:

    I have heard of him before, but after watching his documentary “healing spell” I was turned on to the full story

    about Dr jaj. He is a man who has the Cure for AIDS/HIV and every kind of

    illness, through a whole foods vegetarian diet and natural herbs, what he calls Electric Foods. He went to herbal school college,

    and has thousands of testimonials of healing people with Herpes, HIV AIDS, and HPV several other

    illnesses. Lisa “Left Eye” Lopes of TLC was cured of Herpes by him and she was so moved by his knowledge that she went on

    to spread the word about him in every way she could. She also opened a Cultural/Healing Center for Children in USA

    before she passed away tragically. This all inspired me that i had to contact Dr jaj, because i was having AIDS

    which could not be cure but was only managed, when i contacted Dr. jaj, he sent me some herbs which i took, and now i can tell you, i

    have been totally cured of AIDS, My Name is ROSE, I am from the South Carolina, Please if you have any form

    of illness especially STD,Infertility,HIV etc. you can contact him immediately through his Email Address drjajspellhome@gmail.com or you can also call/whatsaap him on his number
    wowww

  6. Michael G Bruce says:

    Get rid of all kinds of Herpes with Natural Root and Herbs, i was once infected with Herpes Genital Warts and after using Dr Olori Herbal Medicine for couple of weeks i couldn’t trace it anymore, i even went for a checkup and there was my test came out Negative. Get Your cure today from Dr Olori contact via email
    droloriherbalcenter@gmail.com

  7. Donald says:

    i want to tell the world how i was cured of HIV by Dr.Noble although it looks unreal and unbelievable but my dear it is real and i have proof for it
    i was HIV positive for 5 years until Dr.Noble cured me .
    Before i was cured i saw hell, my life was a night mare i was only existing and not living , my wife divorced me my family member abandoned me and my friends where not there to run to , i search all through for a solution but couldn’t find any , i was been scammed by scammers on the internet , i was at the edge of giving up when i saw a testimony of one Mr.Philip who was cured by Dr.noble and i was moved to contact him although i was still sceptical and doubting but i have no option , immediately i contacted him , he replied my mail and we latter talked like father and son via a telephone call and he promised to cure my HIV within 2 weeks.He prepared a very powerful herbal medicine for me which he sent to me via DHL and within 2 weeks of my medication i went for a test at the hospital i was confirmed HIV negative it was like a dream to me, i couldn’t believe my eyes. it a year now am still HIV negative,i have gone to 4 different hospitals for a HIV test and they have all confirmed that am HIV negative , all thanks to Peter wise popularly know as Dr.Noble .
    you can reach him to get cure of any sickness and disease like ALS, Diabetes , HIV and AIDS stroke , Herpes etc via call or whatsapp him +2349059610643

  8. gorege vanisa says:

    Am Gorege vanisa by name, i was diagnosed with Herpes for 7 years i lived in pain with the knowledge that i wasn’t going to ever be well again i contacted so many herbal doctors on this issue and wasted a large sum of money but my condition never got better i was determined to get my life back so one day i saw mr josha post on how Dr abaka saved him from the VIRUS with his herbal medicine i contacted Dr abaka on his email address drabakaspelltemple@gmail.com we spoke on the issue i told him all that i went through and he told me not to worry that everything will be fine again so he prepared the medicine and send it to me through courier service and told me how to use it,after 14 days of usage I went to see the doctor for test ,then the result was negative,am the happiest man on earth now. this testimony is real.thanks to Dr abaka God bless you. you can also reach him on his number +2349063230051.

  9. ola says:

    I have heard of him before, but after watching his documentary “healing spell” I was turned on to the full story

    about Dr jaj. He is a man who has the Cure for AIDS/HIV and every kind of

    illness, through a whole foods vegetarian diet and natural herbs, what he calls Electric Foods. He went to herbal school college,

    and has thousands of testimonials of healing people with Herpes, HIV AIDS, and HPV several other

    illnesses. Lisa “Left Eye” Lopes of TLC was cured of Herpes by him and she was so moved by his knowledge that she went on

    to spread the word about him in every way she could. She also opened a Cultural/Healing Center for Children in USA

    before she passed away tragically. This all inspired me that i had to contact Dr jaj, because i was having AIDS

    which could not be cure but was only managed, when i contacted Dr. jaj, he sent me some herbs which i took, and now i can tell you, i

    have been totally cured of AIDS, My Name is ROSE, I am from the South Carolina, Please if you have any form

    of illness especially STD,Infertility,HIV etc. you can contact him immediately through his Email Address drjajspellhome@gmail.com or you can also call/whatsaap him on his number

  10. pamela says:

    I have been suffering from HIV over 3 years of my marriage and it was really difficult and heartbreaking for me because the symptoms were very terrible and difficult for me, i search for cure, went to different hospital but still no hope until i saw a testimonies of someone who cure of HIV by Dr okosun i took the chance to contact the Dr okosun who have the natural cure to HIV, he assure me of his herbal medication which i listen to his advice and i bought his herbal medication and i used it as instructed by the Dr okosun, in a month time i went to the hospital for scan and they confirm that there is no trace or sign of HIV in me and now am happy and gladly with my family. contact Dr okosun for more information and advice contact him via email

    Dr.okosunspellalter@gmai.com or you can also call him on +2347060571038

  11. madeline ashley says:

    I was diagnose 2015 and find out I’m HIV positive.I was scared because there is no cure for HIV/AIDS but today some people still don’t believe that there is cure for HIV, it can only be cured through Africans root and herbs,and our doctor’s here in USA few of them know’s about the African herbal medicine can cure Hiv but they chooses to hide it from us just to make a sales of ARV DRUGS. I did a research online finding way to get rid of my disease,I saw a comment about a herbal doctor on internet Name Dr Alabi who has cured several disease with his powerful herbal medicine, I contacted him on whats-app, chat with him explain my self to him.He said he can cure hiv perfectly well , he gave me his request which i send to him. within 5 days he sent me the herbal medicine through ups courier delivering service And told me how to take the medicine for 3 weeks to get cured,I did for 3 weeks, within this 3 weeks i notice a very big change in my health and i new some thing great has happened then i went to confirm my result it was absolutely Negative.The doctor who new i was hiv positive was asking me how come i am negative, what did it took to get cure and were did i get this medicine from and how did i get rid of it I told him every thing about the herbal medicine that cure me. imagine doctor telling me not to let anyone know about it,I wasn’t shock though i knew they know about the herbal cure but chose to hide it in other to make sales on ARV DRUGS,if you are HIV positive please contact my savior dr.alabiherbalhome@gmail.com
    or WHATSAPP him through this number +2348115204568

Leave a comment

By submitting your comment, your consent to our privacy policy is deemed to be given.